Index » Beatmaps » Map Requests » Tears for Fears vs. Eric Prydz - Shout vs. Pjanoo

https://osu.ppy.sh/beatmapsets/27222#osu/91418

Map has a special place in my heart, I remember this being one of the first graved sets I've downloaded when I started playing this game.
02:19:468 (1) - Fix this slider though, perfect curve sliders like this get converted to catmull on clients before late 2012 and we can't have this slider looking cursed.

Hard:
02:19:468 (1) - We will definitely want to convert this to something non perfect curve lol

My suggestion is to change the line from:
72,368,139468,6,0,P|336:176|112:16,1,700
to:
72,368,139468,6,0,C|71:368|113:381|157:385|201:378|242:361|277:335|306:301|326:262|336:219|335:175|325:132|305:93|276:60|240:34|199:18|155:12|112:16,1,700

This was created with my Perfect Curve to Catmull converter, it's not perfect but pretty damn close

Digitalfear117 wrote:

Hard:
02:19:468 (1) - We will definitely want to convert this to something non perfect curve lol

My suggestion is to change the line from:
72,368,139468,6,0,P|336:176|112:16,1,700
to:
72,368,139468,6,0,C|71:368|113:381|157:385|201:378|242:361|277:335|306:301|326:262|336:219|335:175|325:132|305:93|276:60|240:34|199:18|155:12|112:16,1,700

This was created with my Perfect Curve to Catmull converter, it's not perfect but pretty damn close

It's good enough, looks almost exactly like the perfect curve slider actually

Perfect curve slider has been replaced with my extremely similar Catmull on the Hard diff. The 2B note at the start of the Normal difficulty has also been fixed

Should be okay for ranked, however there are a lot of hitsound differences between difficulties, don't know if we should fix them up first.

Obivously Taiko HS discrepancies that don't apply to the standard diffs can be ignored, but there is like 100 hitsound differences so I didn't feel like cleaning this list up lol

Easy:
00:59:485 - is missing (Clap, Finish) which exists in Normal, Hard
01:00:199 - is missing (Clap, Finish) which exists in Normal, MM's Taiko
01:02:341 - is missing (Clap, Whistle) which exists in Normal, Hard
01:03:770 - is missing (Whistle, Clap) which exists in Hard, MM's Taiko
01:04:722 - is missing (Whistle, Clap) which exists in Normal, Hard, MM's Taiko
01:31:621 - is missing (Finish, Clap) which exists in Normal, Hard
01:34:716 - is missing (Whistle) which exists in Normal, Hard
01:35:192 - is missing (Whistle) which exists in Normal, Hard
01:35:668 - is missing (Finish) which exists in Normal, Hard
01:38:524 - is missing (Whistle) which exists in Normal, Hard
01:39:000 - is missing (Whistle) which exists in Normal, Hard
01:41:381 - is missing (Whistle) which exists in Normal, Hard
01:41:857 - is missing (Whistle) which exists in Normal, Hard
01:42:095 - is missing (Finish, Whistle) which exists in Normal, Hard
01:45:904 - is missing (Whistle) which exists in Normal, Hard
01:47:570 - is missing (Whistle) which exists in Normal, Hard
01:48:998 - is missing (Whistle) which exists in Normal, Hard
01:49:474 - is missing (Clap, Whistle) which exists in Normal, Hard, MM's Taiko
02:15:183 - is missing (Whistle) which exists in Normal, Hard
02:15:659 - is missing (Clap, Finish) which exists in Normal, Hard, MM's Taiko
02:16:135 - is missing (Clap, Finish) which exists in Normal, Hard, MM's Taiko
02:16:611 - is missing (Clap, Finish) which exists in Normal, Hard, MM's Taiko
02:17:088 - is missing (Clap, Finish) which exists in Normal, Hard, MM's Taiko
02:25:181 - is missing (Whistle) which exists in Normal, Hard
02:29:942 - is missing (Whistle, Clap) which exists in Normal, Hard
02:53:747 - is missing (Whistle) which exists in Normal, Hard
02:55:651 - is missing (Whistle) which exists in Normal, Hard
03:02:078 - is missing (Clap) which exists in Normal, MM's Taiko
03:10:886 - is missing (Finish) which exists in Normal, Hard
03:11:362 - is missing (Whistle, Clap) which exists in Normal, Hard
03:11:838 - is missing (Finish) which exists in Normal, Hard
03:12:790 - is missing (Finish) which exists in Normal, Hard
03:27:073 - is missing (Clap) which exists in Hard, MM's Taiko

Normal:
00:55:676 - is missing (Whistle) which exists in Easy, Hard
01:00:913 - is missing (Clap, Finish) which exists in Easy, Hard
01:03:770 - is missing (Whistle, Clap) which exists in Hard, MM's Taiko
01:04:722 - is missing (Finish, Clap) which exists in Easy, Hard, MM's Taiko
01:31:621 - is missing (Whistle, Clap) which exists in Easy, Hard
01:34:239 - is missing (Whistle, Clap) which exists in Hard, MM's Taiko
01:35:668 - is missing (Whistle) which exists in Easy, Hard
01:36:144 - is missing (Whistle, Finish) which exists in Hard, MM's Taiko
01:42:095 - is missing (Clap, Whistle) which exists in Easy, Hard
01:45:190 - is missing (Finish) which exists in Easy, Hard
01:50:427 - is missing (Clap) which exists in Easy, MM's Taiko
01:51:141 - is missing (Clap) which exists in Hard, MM's Taiko
01:51:855 - is missing (Clap) which exists in Easy, Hard, MM's Taiko
01:52:331 - is missing (Clap) which exists in Easy, Hard
01:52:569 - is missing (Clap) which exists in Hard, MM's Taiko
02:10:422 - is missing (Clap) which exists in Hard, MM's Taiko
02:11:374 - is missing (Clap) which exists in Easy, Hard, MM's Taiko
02:12:327 - is missing (Clap) which exists in Hard, MM's Taiko
02:13:279 - is missing (Clap) which exists in Easy, Hard, MM's Taiko
02:15:659 - is missing (Whistle, Finish) which exists in Easy, MM's Taiko
02:16:135 - is missing (Whistle, Finish) which exists in Easy, MM's Taiko
02:16:611 - is missing (Whistle, Finish) which exists in Easy, MM's Taiko
02:18:992 - is missing (Clap) which exists in Easy, MM's Taiko
02:32:561 - is missing (Clap) which exists in Hard, MM's Taiko
02:53:747 - is missing (Finish) which exists in Easy, Hard
02:54:937 - is missing (Clap) which exists in Hard, MM's Taiko
02:58:984 - is missing (Whistle) which exists in Easy, Hard
03:02:078 - is missing (Whistle) which exists in Easy, Hard
03:03:268 - is missing (Clap) which exists in Easy, Hard
03:03:506 - is missing (Clap) which exists in Hard, MM's Taiko
03:06:363 - is missing (Clap, Finish) which exists in Easy, MM's Taiko
03:18:979 - is missing (Clap, Finish) which exists in Hard, MM's Taiko
03:22:788 - is missing (Clap) which exists in Hard, MM's Taiko
03:23:740 - is missing (Clap) which exists in Hard, MM's Taiko
03:24:692 - is missing (Clap) which exists in Hard, MM's Taiko
03:25:645 - is missing (Clap) which exists in Hard, MM's Taiko
03:26:597 - is missing (Clap) which exists in Hard, MM's Taiko
03:27:549 - is missing (Clap) which exists in Hard, MM's Taiko

Hard:
00:39:489 - is missing (Whistle) which exists in Easy, Normal
00:41:393 - is missing (Whistle) which exists in Easy, Normal
00:43:298 - is missing (Whistle) which exists in Easy, Normal
00:56:390 - is missing (Clap) which exists in Normal, MM's Taiko
01:00:199 - is missing (Clap, Finish) which exists in Normal, MM's Taiko
01:00:913 - is missing (Finish, Whistle) which exists in Easy, Normal
01:04:722 - is missing (Finish, Whistle) which exists in Easy, Normal
01:28:050 - is missing (Finish) which exists in Easy, Normal, MM's Taiko
01:28:526 - is missing (Clap) which exists in Normal, MM's Taiko
01:29:955 - is missing (Finish) which exists in Normal, MM's Taiko
01:36:144 - is missing (Clap, Finish) which exists in Normal, MM's Taiko
01:39:951 - is missing (Whistle) which exists in Easy, Normal
01:40:905 - is missing (Whistle) which exists in Easy, Normal
01:42:095 - is missing (Clap, Finish) which exists in Easy, Normal
01:43:761 - is missing (Whistle) which exists in Easy, Normal
01:44:713 - is missing (Whistle) which exists in Easy, Normal
01:45:190 - is missing (Whistle) which exists in Easy, Normal
01:45:904 - is missing (Clap) which exists in Easy, Normal
01:49:474 - is missing (Clap) which exists in Normal, MM's Taiko
02:09:946 - is missing (Clap) which exists in Easy, Normal
02:11:851 - is missing (Clap) which exists in Easy, Normal
02:15:659 - is missing (Whistle, Finish) which exists in Easy, MM's Taiko
02:16:135 - is missing (Whistle, Finish) which exists in Easy, MM's Taiko
02:16:611 - is missing (Whistle, Finish) which exists in Easy, MM's Taiko
02:17:564 - is missing (Clap, Whistle) which exists in Easy, Normal
02:18:992 - is missing (Clap, Whistle) which exists in Easy, Normal, MM's Taiko
02:28:514 - is missing (Clap) which exists in Easy, Normal, MM's Taiko
02:28:752 - is missing (Clap, Finish) which exists in Easy, Normal
02:31:370 - is missing (Clap) which exists in Normal, MM's Taiko
02:32:799 - is missing (Clap) which exists in Easy, Normal
02:33:751 - is missing (Clap) which exists in Easy, Normal
02:34:703 - is missing (Clap) which exists in Easy, Normal
02:35:179 - is missing (Whistle, Clap) which exists in Normal, MM's Taiko
02:35:655 - is missing (Clap) which exists in Easy, Normal
02:53:985 - is missing (Whistle, Clap) which exists in Normal, MM's Taiko
02:54:461 - is missing (Clap) which exists in Normal, MM's Taiko
02:55:651 - is missing (Clap, Finish) which exists in Easy, Normal
02:59:222 - is missing (Clap) which exists in Normal, MM's Taiko
03:02:078 - is missing (Clap) which exists in Normal, MM's Taiko
03:02:554 - is missing (Clap) which exists in Normal, MM's Taiko
03:06:363 - is missing (Clap, Finish) which exists in Easy, MM's Taiko
03:09:458 - is missing (Clap) which exists in Easy, Normal
03:09:696 - is missing (Clap) which exists in Easy, Normal
03:12:790 - is missing (Whistle) which exists in Easy, Normal
03:17:551 - is missing (Clap) which exists in Easy, Normal
03:18:979 - is missing (Whistle, Finish) which exists in Normal, MM's Taiko
03:23:264 - is missing (Whistle, Clap) which exists in Easy, MM's Taiko
03:25:169 - is missing (Whistle, Clap) which exists in Easy, MM's Taiko

Okay that's a lot of hitsound differences wtf, that's gonna take so long going through all of them
I wouldn't worry about them too much imo

I’ll go through and take a look at the HS at some point and update them if I feel it’s necessary

hello, i've entered the discussion

ig we're putting more effort into map requests now with proper mods for stuff like hitsounds?

We don’t need to go full fix everything mode, this set is just crazy about how much is different for hitsounds. We can just ignore as long as we all think the hitsounds sound okay for all diffs. I do feeling like matching them up might be nice though

Taiko diff seems good, idk If this entire set is going for ranked considering the amount of fixing needed

StreeX wrote:

Taiko diff seems good, idk If this entire set is going for ranked considering the amount of fixing needed

at least we know taiko needs no fixing xd

question, could we just copy hitsounds from one of these diffs onto the other ones and see which one would have the best results?

Satori wrote:

question, could we just copy hitsounds from one of these diffs onto the other ones and see which one would have the best results?

sounds fine to me

looked at hitsounds in hard, some mistakes that i noticed (those marked with * are optional):
- 01:28:050 (6,8) - missing finish on slider head
- 01:39:476 (1,3) - missing whistle on slider tail
- 01:45:190 (5) - missing clap on slider tail
- 02:27:085 (5) - missing finish on slider head
- 02:27:800 (6) - missing finish on slider tail
- 02:28:514 (1,2) - missing claps
- * 02:33:275 (1,3,5) - would be cool if these had claps
- 02:54:461 (8) - missing whistle on slider head
- * 03:01:602 (6) - would remove whistle here
- 03:02:554 (1) - missing clap
- 03:12:790 (5) - missing whistle on slider head
- * 03:14:218 (1,2) - would be cool if these had claps
- 03:17:551 (5) - missing clap on slider head

the rest should be good i think

Do you mind updating this one? I’m doing homework as I have a big assignment due by the 20th