Index » Beatmaps » Map Requests » Special D - You [Standard, Taiko]

https://osu.ppy.sh/beatmapsets/7334

this is just cuz i like song, the set might not be too great though

Checking the standard set, I don't think it's bad actually, however, the entire set needs a preview point and the easy diff has an open kiai.

Also it seems that easy, normal, and aqua's diff are cut short, but I think they're good as it is tbh. I'll see what others think though

one thing that noticable is that Aqua diff has a preview point at 00:30:186 -

we might be want to use that timestamp for all diffs then

Added preview point for all Standard diffs, fixed several unsnapped kiai too on Hard and Insane diff

also timing point scuffed on Aqua's diff, i fixed it so everything is snapped properly now

also can we make an exception for Aqua's diff, when 00:26:840 - and 00:56:840 - use 36 BPM, it was intentionally used by the mapper to take advantage of slow slider uses there, while the rest of the other standard diffs use single inherited BPM timing

oh i also add the preview point for Taiko diffs and fixed the unsnapped kiais as well (am i allowed to do this though)

personally i would delete roley's diff i don't like the way he has chosen the rhythm in some parts and it's uncomfortable to play.

I would need to look at the changes you guys made on top diff. I downloaded it from bancho just to check what the map originally started as, and it looks rough man.

Digitalfear117 wrote:

I would need to look at the changes you guys made on top diff. I downloaded it from bancho just to check what the map originally started as, and it looks rough man.

yeah, i fixed several minor things like manual lead in time, preview points, and unsnapped kiais

idk if there any problem around the maps themself

-Ady wrote:

personally i would delete roley's diff i don't like the way he has chosen the rhythm in some parts and it's uncomfortable to play.

we can let it unrank that diff only if that's the case, i will wait for other opinions about that singular diff itself

-Ady wrote:

personally i would delete roley's diff i don't like the way he has chosen the rhythm in some parts and it's uncomfortable to play.

i don't agree that we should outright unrank/delete roley's diff, but it definitely needs fixes, so i'll put up a list of mods i'd personally do:
- 00:40:694 (1) - move this here 00:40:834 and adjust it on playfield
- 01:18:611 (2,3,4,5) - move these on top of 1
- 01:25:278 (1) - remove NC
- 01:43:611 (3) - remove this, 01:43:819 (4) - move this to 01:43:715, 01:44:028 (6) - remove this and 01:44:236 (7) - move this to 01:44:132 (yes, all of this is one thing)
- similar type of adjustments as well on 01:47:882 (2,3,4,5,6,1,2,3,4,5,6,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - as rhythm here makes no sense
- 02:53:715 - add a circle here
- 03:02:674 - add a circle here

as for smaller fixes:
- 00:34:653 (4) - move this by one (small) grid left
- 01:27:882 - maybe add a circle here
- 01:45:174 (1,3) - would be nice to move these on top of sliders
- 01:56:215 (6) - maybe removing this circle and adding circles on 01:56:111 and 01:56:319 for cooler rhythm and to follow what 01:52:674 (3,4,5,6) - did
- 01:57:674 (5,6,7,8,9) - similar thing here and to follow 01:54:340 (4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,1) -

that's all from me and roley diff

nevermind, silly me looking at different diff askajdjhkasd

Satori wrote:

i don't agree that we should outright unrank/delete roley's diff, but it definitely needs fixes, so i'll put up a list of mods i'd personally do:
- 00:40:694 (1) - move this here 00:40:834 and adjust it on playfield
- 01:18:611 (2,3,4,5) - move these on top of 1
- 01:25:278 (1) - remove NC
- 01:43:611 (3) - remove this, 01:43:819 (4) - move this to 01:43:715, 01:44:028 (6) - remove this and 01:44:236 (7) - move this to 01:44:132 (yes, all of this is one thing)
- similar type of adjustments as well on 01:47:882 (2,3,4,5,6,1,2,3,4,5,6,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - as rhythm here makes no sense
- 02:53:715 - add a circle here
- 03:02:674 - add a circle here

as for smaller fixes:
- 00:34:653 (4) - move this by one (small) grid left
- 01:27:882 - maybe add a circle here
- 01:45:174 (1,3) - would be nice to move these on top of sliders
- 01:56:215 (6) - maybe removing this circle and adding circles on 01:56:111 and 01:56:319 for cooler rhythm and to follow what 01:52:674 (3,4,5,6) - did
- 01:57:674 (5,6,7,8,9) - similar thing here and to follow 01:54:340 (4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,1) -

that's all from me and roley diff

did some adjustments, lmk ur opinion on it (there are several parts that i intentionally not applied)

Decent map, ranked for my part.