Index » Beatmaps » Map Requests » Grandaddy - Jed's Other Poem (Beautiful Ground)

216 posts | Jump | 1 2 3 4 5 ... 15

Digitalfear117 BAT Manager / Global Moderator / Mr. Ladybug 3,660 posts BAT GMT TMT TMG

2 years ago @Levi @Basil Chapman Hi, this is a veto against this map getting ranked. The offset is incorrect The offset and bpm of this map does not align with the beats correctly. Moving the offset to 28,960 bandaids the issue a little, but I’m not convinced the flat bpm of 120 is correct for this whole section. I would try to get the exact timing but I don’t have my computer and I’m in another state rn Last edited by Digitalfear117 2 years ago, edited 1 time in total.

Digitalfear117 BAT Manager / Global Moderator / Mr. Ladybug 3,660 posts BAT GMT TMT TMG

2 years ago In addition, I have concerns with patterning and rhythm choices throughout the map Last edited by Digitalfear117 2 years ago, edited 1 time in total.

Digitalfear117 BAT Manager / Global Moderator / Mr. Ladybug 3,660 posts BAT GMT TMT TMG

2 years ago I think maps like this should be made to go through a round of modding before being ranked. I understand that the bar for ranking criteria will most likely be lower here than on bancho, however things like offset, and bpm, and rhythms being utilized correctly should not be compromised on. These things would also help new mappers, as it will show them how they can improve their map! Last edited by Digitalfear117 2 years ago, edited 1 time in total.

Nikku BAT Manager 623 posts BAT TMG

2 years ago a few things i noticed on the insane at first glance, 00 and 00 have no note when that sound has been mapped before and after it, 01 (8) - should be 01, *not going to say much else for now since not sure how much basil actually wants mods on the map but just sending as an example*

Digitalfear117 BAT Manager / Global Moderator / Mr. Ladybug 3,660 posts BAT GMT TMT TMG

2 years ago After major concerns are addressed, this map can probably be safely re-ranked Last edited by Digitalfear117 2 years ago, edited 1 time in total.

Archen Rhythm Incarnate 644 posts

2 years ago Digitalfear117 wrote: @Levi @Basil Chapman Hi, this is a veto against this map getting ranked. The offset is incorrect The offset and bpm of this map does not align with the beats correctly. Moving the offset to 28,960 bandaids the issue a little, but I’m not convinced the flat bpm of 120 is correct for this whole section. I would try to get the exact timing but I don’t have my computer and I’m in another state rn Thanks for addressing! I’ll be sure to update that next time I’m on.

kingkurboh335 Global Moderator / BAT Manager 2,992 posts BAT GMT

2 years ago yeee, unranking this would be a good idea LVL1 | 300 ATK | 200 DEF If this card on the field is destroyed and sent to the GY: For the rest of this turn, you take no battle damage.

Archen Rhythm Incarnate 644 posts

2 years ago Nikku wrote: a few things i noticed on the insane at first glance, 00 and 00 have no note when that sound has been mapped before and after it, 01 (8) - should be 01, *not going to say much else for now since not sure how much basil actually wants mods on the map but just sending as an example* I’ll check this too.

kingkurboh335 Global Moderator / BAT Manager 2,992 posts BAT GMT

2 years ago i said i was gonna mod the insane diff top lol LVL1 | 300 ATK | 200 DEF If this card on the field is destroyed and sent to the GY: For the rest of this turn, you take no battle damage.

kingkurboh335 Global Moderator / BAT Manager 2,992 posts BAT GMT

2 years ago wait LVL1 | 300 ATK | 200 DEF If this card on the field is destroyed and sent to the GY: For the rest of this turn, you take no battle damage.

kingkurboh335 Global Moderator / BAT Manager 2,992 posts BAT GMT

2 years ago i need to hitsound the diff i made! LVL1 | 300 ATK | 200 DEF If this card on the field is destroyed and sent to the GY: For the rest of this turn, you take no battle damage.

Nikku BAT Manager 623 posts BAT TMG

2 years ago

Levi Project Lead / Developer 1,910 posts ADMIN DEV

2 years ago And that's the reason why I am not responsible for maps folks

Nikku BAT Manager 623 posts BAT TMG

2 years ago lol Last edited by Nikku 2 years ago, edited 1 time in total.

Archen Rhythm Incarnate 644 posts

2 years ago Updates so far -all difficulties timing offset has been patched -Propper preview point **INSANE** -a difficulty buff, cause it was too easy. -Patterns will continue to be snapped to the grid, but tried to optimize using more squares and triangles -The quick 3 note bursts have repeated throughout to improve consistency. **KURBOH’S HARD** -hit sounds (presumably) **OPOSH’S NORMAL** -nothing **EASY** -Timing improvements -Using sliders instead of circles as those are easier to hit. Last edited by Archen 2 years ago, edited 1 time in total.

216 posts | Jump | 1 2 3 4 5 ... 15